|
Serial Commas
The term "serial comma" may
sound a little strange, but it's simply the technical term for a comma
that comes before the last item in a series or list. The following excerpts were taken from
Wikipedia's article entitled "Serial Comma."
---------
The serial comma (also known as the Oxford comma or Harvard comma) is
the comma used immediately before a grammatical conjunction (nearly
always and or or) that precedes the last item in a list of
three or more items. The phrase "ham, chips, and eggs" is an example
that is written with the serial comma, while "ham, chips and eggs" is
identical in meaning, but does not include the serial comma.
There is much disagreement about the use of the serial comma. It is
nearly standard use in American English, but much less common in British
English.
Resolving ambiguity
Use of the serial comma can remove ambiguity.
Consider: "My favorite types of sandwiches are BLT, ham, peanut butter
and jam and cream cheese." This is ambiguous because "jam" may be paired
with either "peanut butter" or "cream cheese," or all three ingredients
can be grouped together. A comma after "jam" can clarify this sentence:
"My favorite types of sandwiches are BLT, ham, peanut butter and jam,
and cream cheese."
Creating ambiguity
Use of the serial comma can introduce ambiguity, in particular where the
last noun phrase but two in the list is singular.
Consider "They went to Oregon with Betty, a maid, and a cook." The
presence of the last comma creates the possibility that Betty is a maid,
reasonably allowing it to be read either as a list of two people or as a
list of three people, context aside. On the other hand, removing the
comma leaves the possibility that Betty is both a maid and a cook, so in
this case neither the use nor the avoidance of the serial comma resolves
the ambiguity.
Usage
The Chicago Manual of Style, Strunk and White's Elements of
Style, most authorities on American English and Canadian English,
and some authorities on British English—for example, Oxford
University Press and Fowler's Modern English Usage—recommend
the use of the serial comma. Newspaper style guides—such as those
published by The New York Times, the Associated Press, The
Times newspaper in the United Kingdom, and the Canadian Press—recommend against it, possibly for economy of space.¹
---------
You're simply thrilled that I brought up another controversial grammar
topic, aren't you? Honestly, I was always taught to use a comma before
the last item in a list, but apparently there are many other people who
were taught to omit it. No matter what you were taught, keep in mind
that most manuals on American and Canadian English recommend using the
serial comma to prevent confusion.
According to Wikipedia, even the United States Government Printing
Office's Style Manual mandates the use of the serial comma, like
in the phrase "red, white, and blue." If it's good enough for government
work...
Additional Resources:
●
Would you like to receive the Weekly Grammar Tips newsletter in
your
email inbox? Enter your email address below to receive
FREE Weekly Grammar Tips. Your email
address is safe with me.
●
Read past grammar tips in the
Weekly
Grammar Tips Archive. Be sure
to add the archive page to your bookmarks or
favorites folder for
future reference.
●
Do you need a second set of eyes? Read more about my proofreading
and editing
services here.
¹Wikipedia
contributors, "Serial comma," Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia,
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Serial_comma&oldid=84032468
(accessed October 29, 2006). |